Finding Great British Cheese
You don't need to spend a fortune to eat well. But knowing where to look, what to ask for, and what the labels really mean can transform your cheese experience from mundane to magnificent.
Supermarket vs Artisan: The Real Difference
Supermarket Cheese
Most supermarket "Cheddar" is made in industrial facilities from pasteurised, standardised milk. It's consistent, affordable, and perfectly fine for sandwiches and cooking. The UK's major Cheddar manufacturers produce millions of tonnes annually.
Pros: Affordable, convenient, consistent, widely available
Cons: Limited flavour complexity, rarely uses raw milk, no maker identity
Artisan/Farmhouse Cheese
Artisan cheese is typically made in small batches, often from a single herd's milk, using traditional methods. The maker knows the cows, controls every stage, and each wheel reflects the season it was made.
Pros: Complex flavours, sense of place, supporting small farms, extraordinary range
Cons: More expensive, variable (which is partly the point), shorter shelf life, harder to find
The Middle Ground
Several excellent producers operate between these extremes — larger than farmhouse, but far more careful than industrial. Quicke's, Barber's, and the Wensleydale Creamery all make superb cheese at accessible prices.
Understanding Labels
PDO (Protected Designation of Origin)
The gold standard. The cheese must be made in a specific geographic area using defined methods and local ingredients. Examples: Stilton, West Country Farmhouse Cheddar, Yorkshire Wensleydale.
PGI (Protected Geographical Indication)
Slightly less strict — at least one stage of production must occur in the named region. Examples: Swaledale, Bonchester.
"Farmhouse"
Traditionally means made on a farm using milk from the farm's own herd. However, the term isn't legally protected and is sometimes used loosely.
"Artisan" / "Handmade"
Also not legally defined in the UK, but generally indicates small-scale, hands-on production. Look for named makers as a better indicator of quality.
"Cloth-Bound" / "Cloth-Wrapped"
The cheese is wrapped in muslin cloth and larded with butter or lard before aging. This traditional method allows the cheese to breathe, develop a natural rind, and concentrate flavour. Industrial Cheddar uses plastic-wrapped block aging instead.
"Raw" / "Unpasteurised"
Made from milk that hasn't been heat-treated. This preserves the natural bacterial flora, producing more complex flavours. UK law permits raw milk cheese but requires it to be clearly labelled. Raw milk hard cheeses are safe — the extended aging period eliminates harmful bacteria.
"Vegetarian"
Made with non-animal rennet. Traditional cheese uses calf rennet (an enzyme from the stomach of young calves). Vegetarian alternatives include microbial rennet and thistle rennet. Most supermarket cheese is vegetarian; many artisan cheeses use traditional animal rennet.
Price Guide: What You Can Expect
Budget (Under 5 per kg)
- Supermarket own-brand Cheddar (mild to mature)
- Block Red Leicester and Double Gloucester
- Processed cheese slices (not recommended, but honest)
At this price, you're getting industrial cheese. It works for cooking and everyday sandwiches. For the best value, buy mature or extra mature — the stronger flavour means you use less.
Mid-Range (5-15 per kg)
- Named-producer Cheddar (Quicke's, Barber's, Davidstow)
- Branded Stilton (Cropwell Bishop, Colston Bassett)
- Good Wensleydale, Lancashire, Caerphilly
- Supermarket "finest" ranges
This is the sweet spot for many consumers. You're getting cheese with genuine character and provenance. The Colston Bassett Stilton in Waitrose is a genuine artisan cheese at a reasonable price.
Premium (15-30 per kg)
- Montgomery's Cheddar, Kirkham's Lancashire
- Tunworth, Baron Bigod
- Stichelton, Sparkenhoe Red Leicester
- Isle of Mull Cheddar, Cornish Yarg
These are the cheeses that win international awards. The price reflects small-scale production, long aging periods, and exceptional care. For a cheese board or a special meal, they're transformative.
Specialist (Over 30 per kg)
- Rare seasonal cheeses, small-batch single-herd productions
- Washed-rind specials, limited-edition wheels
- Direct-from-maker aged reserves
For turophiles and special occasions. At this level, you're buying cheese as a luxury product comparable to fine wine.
Where to Buy
Online Specialists
- Neal's Yard Dairy — The standard-bearer for British cheese retail. Expert curation, excellent condition
- The Courtyard Dairy — Yorkshire-based, outstanding selection of farmhouse cheeses
- Paxtons & Whitfield — Britain's oldest cheesemonger (est. 1797), with an impeccable Jermyn Street shop
- The Fine Cheese Co. — Bath-based, with beautiful accompaniments
- The Cheese Shed — Devon-based, excellent West Country selection
Supermarkets
Waitrose leads for cheese selection, stocking genuine artisan producers alongside own-brand. Marks & Spencer has improved significantly, and Sainsbury's Taste the Difference range includes some worthwhile options. Aldi and Lidl occasionally have surprisingly good continental cheeses.
Farmers' Markets
Often the best way to discover local makers. Many small producers sell only at markets and through local shops. Arrive early for the best selection.
Direct from Makers
Many farmhouse cheesemakers now sell direct through their own websites. This is often the freshest option and ensures maximum revenue goes to the maker.
Storing Cheese Properly
Bad storage ruins good cheese. Follow these rules:
- Wrap in wax paper or cheese paper — never cling film, which makes cheese sweat and develops off-flavours
- Store in the fridge — ideally in a dedicated cheese compartment or vegetable drawer (slightly warmer and more humid than the main shelf)
- Bring to room temperature — remove cheese from the fridge 45-60 minutes before serving. Cold cheese has muted flavour
- Rewrap after each use — in fresh paper to prevent cross-contamination
- Separate strong cheeses — blue cheese aromas will migrate to everything nearby
- Hard cheese lasts longest — aged Cheddar keeps for weeks properly wrapped. Soft cheese should be eaten within days of cutting
The Best Value Strategy
If you want the most cheese pleasure for your money:
- Buy one excellent cheese rather than several mediocre ones
- Choose seasonal — cheeses at their peak age are the best value for flavour
- Visit specialist shops and ask for recommendations — they'll match your taste and budget
- Try lesser-known varieties — the hype premium on famous names doesn't always mean better flavour
- Buy whole or half wheels for groups or parties — much better value per kilo than pre-cut portions
Product mentions and shop recommendations are editorial. Some links may be affiliate partnerships — see our affiliate disclosure for details.